ASIDES | Qur'anic exegesis |  |
Blogging the Qur’an
Posted by Zahed Amanullah on January 8, 2008
For all its importance to Muslims, the Qur'an has not been methodically explained to a wide non-Muslim audience. Considering the cherry picking done by non-Muslims and Muslims alike, an objective public reading doesn't sound like a bad idea. The online magazine Slate ran a blog series by Jewish columnist David Plotz covering the Bible that was largely successful (if uncontroversial) due to the genuine sense of introspection and a reasonably objective approach.
It is perhaps that sense that Muslim writer and "cultural critic" Ziauddin Sardar hopes to provide as he begins " blogging the Qur'an" on a weekly basis in Britain's Guardian newspaper and website. Before people think that the blog series will be a fawning exercise in hyperbole, Sardar is well known for his "scepticism" as outlined in a range of books including the wonderful Desperately Seeking Paradise. It is the kind of approach that promises to be influential to the people who need it most - Muslims who interpret the Qur'an in a way that exacerbates the clash with modernity and non-Muslims who do the same. Both groups are sympathetic enough to Sardar - to his humility and to his constructive critique - to grant him a willing ear.
It should be noted that Sardar has been beaten to the punch by Islam critic Robert Spencer, who started blogging the Qur'an on a weekly basis in May of last year. Looking at his latest entry, you'll find a surprisingly sedate description of the selected verses scattered with varying degrees of misinterpretation (it's not "up to Allah who believes and who doesn’t," Robert... it's that humans have been given free will to choose their destiny). Still, the idea of explaining the Qur'an in depth to an audience that is already predisposed to despise it is not a very efficient use of influence.
Interestingly, the public commentary will be limited to selected e-mails and responses from Sardar rather than the mudslinging comment threads found on Islam-related blog entries on the Guardian's Comment is Free website. Those (on both sides) who relish the sport of verbal jousting will have to resort to substance, honesty, and patience in their interactions. Letters to the editor in the Internet age? Doesn't sound like a bad idea.
[Zia Sardar is speaking on a panel discussion this Friday at the City Circle in London this Friday on the Pakistan crisis.]
We try to remove any comments that do not conform to our netiquette guidelines. If any comments remain that are in violation, please let us know. The presence of offending comments does not necessarily reflect the views of the editors of altmuslim.
Mr. Amanullah: On 9/11, and in the immediate aftermath, I was proud of my country because there were no counterattacks against Muslims. I was proud of the fact that our leaders stood up and announced that Islam is a "religion of peace." I, along with the vast majority of Americans, simply assumed that Islam was just another religion - i.e., be nice, don't lie, cheat or steal, pray once in a while.
In the months and years following 9/11, I've been doing my own independent research on Islam, and I have discovered, much to my surprise, that Islam is NOT "just another religion." Islam is unique in many respects, but most importantly, I sincerely believe that anyone who reads the Qu'ran from the perspective of "I believe this is the immutable word of Allah/God" will inevitably exhibit a range of pathologies that do not fit within contemporary Western society. To insist otherwise means that you: 1. Have not read the Qu'ran; or 2. You are part of the large group of Muslims who feel that it is their duty to cover-up the "bad" parts of the Qu'ran from the infidel.
Robert Spencer will someday be viewed as a hero - the lone Westerner who dared to understand the Qu'ran and the Hadith, who dared to research Islam with a critical eye, and who exposed what he found to the rest of humanity.
Your glib dismissal of one of Mr. Spencer's statements (regarding free will) is, according to Mr. Spencer, wrong. Of course, Mr. Spencer quotes directly from the Qu'ran as well as other historic sources to buttress his argument (as he always does.) I invite you to read Mr. Spencer's rebuttal (at http://www.jihadwatch.org) and to provide a counterstatement (but please, adhere to the same level of discourse as Mr. Spencer, i.e., references are required.)
Thanks.
Mr. Amanullah,
Robert's specific response to your erroneous statement is found below:
http://www.jihadwatch.org/archives/019497.php#comments
As is typical, you refute a point by Spencer with absolutely no references to support your claim, whereas Robert has substantiated his with , yeah you guessed it, the Qur'an and Islamic sources like the Tanwîr al-Miqbâs min Tafsîr Ibn ‘Abbâs and Ibn Kathir.
How can you expect anyone to take your words seriously when this is what you consider intellectual debate.
Do you dare care to respond, Sir? - Posted by awake on January 9, 2008 at 01:39 PM
Robert allies himself with the extremists in their common interpretation of Islam being a religion of endless conflict. I am working to promote in my own way a practice of Islam - regardless of the differences of opinion within it - that is respectful of others and exists peaceably within pluralistic societies, Muslim and non-Muslim. I stand by my opinion (as does Zia Sardar, who agreed with my stance about free will on his blog today), but I also choose not to let myself be distracted from this important work by either Robert or the extremists.
So thank you for your comments, but that's all I'm going to say about this.
- Posted by zahed (london, england) on January 9, 2008 at 04:43 PM
Page 1 of 1
Comments for this article have been archived and no further comments are allowed.
|
|
|
altmuslim this week - february 1, 2010 - This week, a controversial autopsy report on the killing of Imam Luqman Abdullah raises questions, the trial conviction this week of Aafia Siddiqui in New York raises even more questions, and a report in Harper's alleges that suicides at Guantanamo were cover-ups and raises yet more questions. Enough questions. Who has answers? 
|
Win tickets to see “Journey to Mecca” in London - Voting for the Brass Crescent Awards has begun and for our British participants, we're offering five pairs of tickets to see a special IMAX screening of " Journey to Mecca," a documentary that tells the story of Ibn Battuta and the hajj (November 16, 2009)
Treachery at Fort Hood - American Muslims, particularly those serving in the US Armed Forces, should consider the killing of soldiers at Fort Hood an act of betrayal and treachery, regardless of the political sphere surrounding America's wars overseas. (November 5, 2009)
|
|
| |
|
altmuslim review 032 - Muslim writers everywhere! We speak about the new wave of Western Muslim literature and interview two authors with recently released books. Our own Irfan Yusuf talks about his memoir, Once Were Radicals and Reza Aslan tells us more about his second book, How to Win a Cosmic War (June 11, 2009)
altmuslim review 031 - Oh, Bama! What does the election of Barack Obama mean for American Muslims, who were both courted and shunned during a long campaign? We speak with American Muslim Democratic activists who were gathered in Washington for the historic inauguration. (March 5, 2009)
|
|
Recent and upcoming talks and offsite articles by altmuslim contributors
Al-Awlaki, a new public enemy, Zahed Amanullah, The Guardian, Comment is Free, December 30, 2009.
Islamophonic: Review of the year, Riazat Butt, Zahed Amanullah and David Shariatmadari, Cif Belief (The Guardian), December 18, 2009.
Fort Hood has enough victims already, Wajahat Ali, Comment is Free (The Guardian), November 6, 2009
The pitfalls of filming Muhammad, Shahed Amanullah, The Guardian, Comment is Free, November 4, 2009.
Children of Dust (published by HarperOne, an imprint of HarperCollins), the first book by longtime altmuslim.com contributor Ali Eteraz, is released in the US, Canada, and the UK on October 13, 2009.
Shahed will be attending the m100 Sansoucci Colloquium in Potsdam, Germany, September 14-16, 2009. He will be moderating a panel discussion on the Danish cartoon crisis with Denis MacShane MP, Jasim Al-Azzawi (Al Jazeera English), and Flemming Rose (Jyllands Posten).
Associate Editor Wajahat Ali's play "The Domestic Crusaders" is having its premiere at the Nuyorican Poets Cafe in New York City, NY, September 11, 2009. The play will continue through Sunday, October 11, 2009.
Shahed will be moderating or participating in three panel discussions at the Islamic Society of North America's annual convention, including Muslim Journalists: The View from the Inside, Supporting Social Entrepreneurs and Civic Leaders, and Blogistan: Muslim Americans on the Web in Washington, DC, July 3-6, 2009.
State-sponsored Sufism, Ali Eteraz, Foreign Policy, June 10, 2009.
Pushing the Envelope Without Breaking It, Shahed Amanullah, The Mosque in Morgantown, June 2, 2009.
Obama in Egypt: Let the unsaid be said, Zahed Amanullah, Patheos.com, May 28, 2009.
Zahed will be a panelist at Divan 2.0, a debate on the future of the Muslim internet sponsored by the Radical Middle Way at the London School of Economics in London, England, May 22, 2009.
Once Were Radicals (published by Allen and Unwin), the first book by Associate Editor Irfan Yusuf, is released in Australia, May 4, 2009.
Shahed and Wajahat will be speaking at the 3rd Annual Leadership Summit presented by the Council for the Advancement of Muslim Professionals in Princeton, NJ, May 2, 2009.
Shahed will be leading a workshop on Media Strategies & Techniques at the Muslim Leaders of Tomorrow conference in New York, NY, April 24-25, 2009.
Bringing it all back home, Wajahat Ali, The Guardian, Comment is Free, April 9, 2009.
Zahed will be conducting a two day workshop on Blogging and New Media for Italian students at the United States Embassy, Rome, Italy, April 8-9, 2009.
Crusading for Modern Islamic Art, Shahed Amanullah, Beliefnet, March 26, 2009.
Wajahat will be speaking at the Muslim Leaders of Tomorrow conference in Doha, Qatar (January 16-19, 2009)
Finding the middle ground, Hesham Hassaballa, Philadelphia Inquirer, January 8, 2009.
|
|
Media appearances and analysis featuring altmuslim editors
Muslims say new security rules unfair, ineffective - ''Muslims are doing their duty. Muslim parents are being attentive. It's the TSA that's not being attentive. It's the TSA that's not doing its duty," said Shahed Amanullah, an editor at the Web site altmuslim.com. "There's nothing more that Muslims can do than turn in their own families." (January 7, 2010)
US Muslims & media… Lost love - "We have a big problem; it’s that other people are shaping the story about us," Shahed Amanullah, editor-in-chief of altmuslim.com, told IslamOnline.net. (December 16, 2009)
Moves to Seize Mosques Spark Outrage - "I'm extremely skeptical that the link between these mosques and this organization is so strong as to merit the seizing of a considerable amount of assets that do a lot of good for the Muslim community," says Shahed Amanullah, a prominent Muslim blogger based in Austin. "The government better be prepared to make a very good case, because this is unprecedented." (November 17, 2009)
Muslim Prayer Day Illustrates Dynamics of Free Speech in U.S. - "Some popular commentators and bloggers, such as Zahed Amanullah of the Web site altmuslim and Aziz Poonawalla of the blog City of Brass, were critical of its timing, coming so close to the end of Ramadan and Eid celebrations." (October 23, 2009)
O’s Fall Reading Guide - Children of Dust - "Ali Eteraz's memoir, Children of Dust, describes this ardent young Muslim's picaresque journey from a brutal Pakistani madrassa (oddly reminiscent of a British boys' school) to America's Bible Belt ("Allahbama," in his devout but increasingly modern eyes), where he braved the sexual fantasyland of AOL and zealously warded off temptation in miniskirts... his adventures are a heavenly read." (October 14, 2009)
|
|
Digg this
Tweet this
