COMMENT | Australia's Sheikh Hilaly |  |
The sheik must go
Disparaging non-Muslim Australians as "convicts" was the latest in a string of inexplicable comments. Australia's Sheik Hilaly must now surely resign or be sacked.
By Irfan Yusuf, January 12, 2007

Fourteen centuries ago in the ancient city of Mecca, the prophet Muhammad made the following clear unambiguous statement: "No Arab is superior to a non-Arab and no non-Arab is superior to an Arab. No white man is superior to a black man, and no black man is superior to a white man."
He said these words in Arabic. I've used an English translation. I could also use a translation in French, Swahili or Punjabi. The message would be the same. When it comes to racism, Islamic theology adopts a zero-tolerance policy.
Sheik Hilaly speaks the same language as the Prophet. On Monday, he went on a national breakfast program on Egyptian TV. He didn't need a translator on this occasion. But instead of following the letter and spirit of the Prophet's teachings, Sheik Hilaly apparently chose to use grossly insulting and racist language to describe his adopted country.
The 11 January 2006 episode of A Current Affair showed excerpts of an interview Sheik Hilaly gave to Egyptian TV when invited to explain his recent controversies in Australia. Let's recap on a few themes from the interview.
Hilaly says Europeans, especially the English, are devious and deceptive. He further claims further claims Muslims came to Australia as free people while Europeans came in chains as convicts.
I hope the Sheik doesn't plan visiting a Bosnian or Albanian mosque upon his return. I also hope he doesn't try to sell his views on racial supremacy to Dr Mustafa Ceric, the Mufti of Bosnia Herzegovina, who visits Australia next month.
Would Sheik Hilaly use convict heritage to denigrate former Islamic Council of Victoria secretary Bilal Cleland (who authored a book entitled Muslims In Australia: A Brief History, and has direct descent from the first and third fleets)? What would he say to tens of thousands of Muslims with at least one Anglo-Australian parent?
Many of the Australian colony's early convicts were Irish Catholics. For over a century, Catholics have been subjected to sectarian prejudice. Prominent Catholics, including Health Minister Tony Abbott, have made public statements expressing empathy with many Muslim migrants and their descendants who are now subjected to sectarian slander. Surely Sheik Hilaly insulting their heritage is hardly an appropriate way for a Muslim leader to reciprocate.
And so what if Australia has a convict heritage? Egypt, the land of Sheik Hilaly's birth, wasn't only land of the Pharaohs. For many years, it was ruled by the Mamluks, a dynasty of slaves. What does that show about Egypt? Would it make sense to make nasty remarks about all Egyptians?
Late last year in a Channel 9 interview, Sheik Hilaly claimed the words of his infamous cat-food speech were misunderstood. But a few days ago, on Egyptian TV, he claimed the reporting of his speech was all a deliberate media conspiracy.
Certainly some of the media commentary may have been over the top. But facts are facts. Sheik Hilaly said what he said, and the meanings of his words were confirmed by multiple translations.
The 11 January ACA episode showed Herald-Sun columnist Andrew Bolt talking about seeing two translations of Hilaly's Egyptian TV interview. Again, the Sheik's old excuse of mistranslation seems to have evaporated.
Bolt described Sheik Hilaly as "the leading mufti, the leading imam in Australia". Bolt might share that assessment with Hilaly supporters, but he shouldn't attribute it to all Australian Muslims. As a Victorian, Bolt would know that Victoria's peak Muslim body last year publicly called for Hilaly to resign and to apologise to all Australians.
Hilaly was appointed to the position of mufti by the Australian Federation of Islamic Councils (AFIC), an umbrella body representing the management bodies of a section of Australia's mosques.
AFIC is currently managed by a court-appointed administrator whose term expires in a month or so. If the outcry from grassroots Muslims (especially women) to last year's comments is anything to go by, the next AFIC administration can expect a tsunami of pressure from ordinary Muslims to sack Hilaly or declare his position redundant.
In the past, AFIC has shown itself to be unrepresentative and unresponsive to Muslim community sentiment. Until last year, it had not had a female on its executive for at least two decades. Most of its executive members were middle-aged first generation migrants. Yet over 40 percent of Australia's Muslims are aged under 40 and were born in Australia.
If AFIC is to be truly representative and responsible, it must act swiftly to remove Sheik Hilaly from his position. Having an elderly non-English speaking mufti representing a community of overwhelmingly young English-speakers is hardly a recipe for good community relations.
Australians of all faiths and no faith in particular are sick and tired of religious leaders like Sheik Hilaly making irresponsible statements. Let's leave verbal pollution to the experts � the politicians and the shock-jocks. Sheik Hilaly must now surely resign or be sacked. It's time Muslim religious leaders brought mufti day to an end once and for all.
Irfan Yusuf is a lawyer and writer based in Sydney, Australia. He is also an occasional lecturer at the School of Politics at Sydney’s Macquarie University. He can be contacted at .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address). This piece originally appeared on Australia’s National Nine News.
We try to remove any comments that do not conform to our netiquette guidelines. If any comments remain that are in violation, please let us know. The presence of offending comments does not necessarily reflect the views of the editors of altmuslim.
I used to sympathy for shiekhs in the west before and hence take their side inspite of their radical intentions but now i am running out of sympathy. I think it is time for muslims in the west to start campaign against such so called shiekhs and re-indoctrinate them.
- Posted by fm (USA) on January 14, 2007 at 03:28 PM
Same here~ After the first comments (about blaming women for sexual crimes against them) I thought 'It must have been taken massively out of context' and assumed it was the media twisting things... But now, I am getting really sick of the insults to non-muslims~ I hope he goes
- Posted by Andraa on February 1, 2007 at 08:02 PM
Its amazing how people jump from Quraanic texts to prejudice, against letter and spirit of Islam, and can be so sanctimonious about it too.
- Posted by Ghulam (South Africa) on February 18, 2007 at 05:51 AM
Page 1 of 1
Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.
|
|
|
altmuslim this week - august 23, 2010 - This week, is there a connection between the heated rhetoric over Park51 and increased hate crimes against Muslims? Also, parallel struggles against anti-Muslim protests in Bradford, England and the innovation (and integration) on display in the 30 Mosques, 30 States and 30 Nights, 30 Grants projects.
|
How Miss USA will push the secret Muslim agenda - A leaked memo confirms a nefarious plot to infiltrate America using the one weapon we can't resist: Total hotness.  (May 17, 2010)
South Park: The controversy continues - In a special for Salon.com, our Associate Editor Wajahat Ali offers his take on the controversy over South Park. If you think South Park's Muslim brouhaha was messy, you should see what's going on in the neighboring town of East Park.  (April 28, 2010)
|
|
|  |
|
altmuslim review 033 - We're baaaaack! We speak about the ongoing controversy over Park51 and what means for the future of lower Manhattan. Also, a discussion with Farhad Chowdhury of the M100 Foundation, which seeks to change the way Muslims pay zakat (August 13, 2010)
altmuslim review 032 - Muslim writers everywhere! We speak about the new wave of Western Muslim literature and interview two authors with recently released books. Our own Irfan Yusuf talks about his memoir, Once Were Radicals and Reza Aslan tells us more about his second book, How to Win a Cosmic War (June 11, 2009)
|
|
Recent and upcoming talks and offsite articles by altmuslim contributors
It's the occupation, stupid, Wajahat Ali, Salon.com, June 4, 2010
Sex and the City 2's stunning Muslim clichés, Wajahat Ali, Salon.com, May 28, 2010
Draw Muhammad Day: Collectively Punishing Muslim Americans, Shahed Amanullah, Huffington Post, May 25, 2010
Shahed will be a guest on the BBC World Service's World, Have Your Say discussing the proposed French ban on niqab (and fines for husbands who compel their wives to wear them) on May 18, 2010.
Even Controversial Views Should Be Protected by Freedom of Speech, Asma Uddin, The Huffington Post, May 7, 2010.
What I understand about Faisal Shahzad, Wajahat Ali, Salon.com, May 6, 2010
No freak out about South Park, Zahed Amanullah, The Guardian, Comment is Free, April 23, 2010.
Shahed will be a guest on the BBC World Service's World, Have Your Say discussing the South Park controversy along with Zarqa Nawaz (Little Mosque on the Prairie) and other guests on April 22, 2010.
Shahed will be a guest on NPR's State of Belief discussing Barack Obama's outreach to the Muslim world, April 17, 2010.
Zahed will be attending a panel discussion entitled " Are Islam and Free Speech Compatible?" in London, England on Friday, March 26, 2010 sponsored by The City Circle. He will be accompanied by Riazat Butt (The Guardian), Hamid Khan (Consultant in Offender and Youth Development), Abu Muntasir (JIMAS), and Dr Usama Hasan.
'Jihad Jane': not the usual suspect, Wajahat Ali, The Guardian, Comment is Free, March 18, 2010.
Al-Awlaki, a new public enemy, Zahed Amanullah, The Guardian, Comment is Free, December 30, 2009.
Islamophonic: Review of the year, Riazat Butt, Zahed Amanullah and David Shariatmadari, Cif Belief (The Guardian), December 18, 2009.
Fort Hood has enough victims already, Wajahat Ali, Comment is Free (The Guardian), November 6, 2009
The pitfalls of filming Muhammad, Shahed Amanullah, The Guardian, Comment is Free, November 4, 2009.
Children of Dust (published by HarperOne, an imprint of HarperCollins), the first book by longtime altmuslim.com contributor Ali Eteraz, is released in the US, Canada, and the UK on October 13, 2009.
Shahed will be attending the m100 Sansoucci Colloquium in Potsdam, Germany, September 14-16, 2009. He will be moderating a panel discussion on the Danish cartoon crisis with Denis MacShane MP, Jasim Al-Azzawi (Al Jazeera English), and Flemming Rose (Jyllands Posten).
Associate Editor Wajahat Ali's play "The Domestic Crusaders" is having its premiere at the Nuyorican Poets Cafe in New York City, NY, September 11, 2009. The play will continue through Sunday, October 11, 2009.
Shahed will be moderating or participating in three panel discussions at the Islamic Society of North America's annual convention, including Muslim Journalists: The View from the Inside, Supporting Social Entrepreneurs and Civic Leaders, and Blogistan: Muslim Americans on the Web in Washington, DC, July 3-6, 2009.
State-sponsored Sufism, Ali Eteraz, Foreign Policy, June 10, 2009.
|
|
Media appearances and analysis featuring altmuslim editors
Helping U.S. reach out to young Muslims worldwide - Soon after Farah Pandith was named last year as the State Department's first special representative to Muslim communities, she sat down with the editor of an independent Muslim website for her first official interview. Altmuslim.com, a forum for opinion and analysis about current issues facing Muslims, was a fitting choice. Pandith has said a strong focus of her work is to reach out to younger Muslims around the world, often those most likely to use the Internet for news and networking. (June 5, 2010)
Censorship is in the ascendant - Zahed Amanullah, associate editor of altmuslim.com, has argued in a national newspaper blog that, since the warning came from an unrepresentative group, the media interest was not justified. As for events of the past – the fatwa on Salman Rushdie, the Danish cartoons, the murder of van Gogh – they were "three incidents over a 20-year period from amongst 1.6 billion people. These things do happen. But we all need a bit of perspective." (April 30, 2010)
Muslims say new security rules unfair, ineffective - ''Muslims are doing their duty. Muslim parents are being attentive. It's the TSA that's not being attentive. It's the TSA that's not doing its duty," said Shahed Amanullah, an editor at the Web site altmuslim.com. "There's nothing more that Muslims can do than turn in their own families." (January 7, 2010)
US Muslims & media… Lost love - "We have a big problem; it’s that other people are shaping the story about us," Shahed Amanullah, editor-in-chief of altmuslim.com, told IslamOnline.net. (December 16, 2009)
Moves to Seize Mosques Spark Outrage - "I'm extremely skeptical that the link between these mosques and this organization is so strong as to merit the seizing of a considerable amount of assets that do a lot of good for the Muslim community," says Shahed Amanullah, a prominent Muslim blogger based in Austin. "The government better be prepared to make a very good case, because this is unprecedented." (November 17, 2009)
|
|